With the death of Roach in 1866, you would think that
Malpaso had ended its hold on those close to Encarnación Ortega.
This was not the case.
Her Attorney, David S. Terry
Bancroft wrote of him:
Perhaps no man in Cal. has had more written about him
than Terry, whose fame cannot with it all, be considered a happy one.
Terry's success in winning the Sánchez case led
to his becoming chief justice of the California Supreme Court. Then he
stabbed a man in an altercation with the San Francisco Vigilance Committee
and he was arrested. Fortunately the man survived or Terry would
have been hung by the committee.
On September 13, 1859, he killed U.S. Senator David C.
Broderick in a duel at Lake Merced, San Francisco.
In the 1880s he represented Sarah Althea Hill in a notorious
law suit against Senator William Sharon of Nevada. Hill claimed Sharon
had married her with a secret contract.
She lost the case and married the much older Terry. When
U.S. Supreme Court Justice Stephen J. Field ruled against her on final
appeal she and Terry vowed vengeance.
By chance the trio were on the same train en route to
San Francisco in August of 1889. During a breakfast stop at a station restaurant
in Lathrop, Terry walked up to Field and slapped him. The justice's bodyguard
shot Terry dead. Sarah became deranged and spent the last forty-five years
of her life at the Stockton State Hospital for the Insane and died there
in 1936.
Her daughter, Vicenta Sanchez Willson
Encarnacion’s eldest daughter and the first to marry had
been Vicenta. Although her husband, Dan Willson, had fought the legal battle
that succeeded in winning her inheritance for her their marriage of twelve
years ended in 1866. Vicenta, twenty-six, had been married when she was
fourteen and had her first child at fifteen.
On July 9, 1866, Willson made a poignant entry in his
diary.
“Dave Hilderbrand went away and took my wife with him.”
Vicenta and Dan were divorced, but Willson did not remain
lonely for long. He married two more times and died on April 14, 1906.
He is buried in Gilroy.
Her son, Gregorio Sanchez
Encarnacion’s only son killed two men on separate occasions
during brawls in San Juan. He was never convicted, but his fortune was
depleted through legal fees and his dissolute life.
In 1888 his wife, Margaret Breen, divorced him on the
same charges Encarnación had used against his father, José
María Sánchez thirty-six years earlier; beating her during
drunken rages.
Gregorio died a poor man in 1905 at the age of sixty.
He was buried in the San Juan Bautista Cemetery in a grave that has never
been found.
Her daughter, Refugia Sanchez McKnight.
Her husband, Thomas J. McKnight, divorced her in
1870. He was given custody of their children.
Her daughter, Virginia Crane, the child bride
"Would to God I had married an Irish or any other kind of girl and
lived happy, instead of marrying such a Mongrel mixture as you are."
This was written by husband, Eugene Munch, in a letter
to Virginia.